Our method for college and university studies
We model each stream of university activity on its own and then add them up: institutional operations, capital spending, student spending, visitor spending, and the earnings premium of alumni who stay in the region. The operations shock is the institution's payroll and purchasing, taken from audited financial statements. We do not also count tuition revenue or state appropriations, because those dollars pay for that same spending.
Student spending needs a counterfactual. Students who moved to the region to enroll, or who would have left to study elsewhere if the institution did not exist, bring spending the region would otherwise lose. Local students who would have stayed anyway do not, so we count off-campus living costs for the first group only. Rent and meal plans paid to the institution are already in operations and come out of student budgets.
For alumni, we estimate the earnings gap between graduates and workers with the next-lower credential from American Community Survey data for the region. We apply it only to graduates still living and working there, discount for those who would have earned the credential elsewhere, and report this workforce stream separately from the spending streams.
Typical inputs we ask for
- Audited financial statements for the study year
- Payroll and headcount, with employee home ZIP codes if available
- Vendor payments with vendor ZIP codes
- Capital spending by project and year
- Enrollment by student county or ZIP of origin, and on-campus versus off-campus housing
- Attendance at commencement, athletics and other campus events
- Completions by award level, plus any alumni location data your advancement office holds
Questions clients ask
Will you count the spending of every student?
No. A student from the same county who would have enrolled somewhere nearby, or not enrolled and stayed home, would have spent money in the region regardless. We count off-campus spending by students who came from outside the region and by local students the institution kept from leaving, and we state the shares and the assumptions behind them in the methodology section.
How is the alumni earnings premium different from the other results?
The spending streams describe activity in one year. The earnings premium describes higher productivity that graduates carry through their working lives, so it depends on assumptions about how long graduates stay in the region and what they would have earned otherwise. We show it as its own line so a reader can see the spending-only total. Our Crowder College study modeled workforce productivity as one of its five streams.
Can the study show a return on state and local funding?
Yes. We can compare total regional economic activity with the public appropriations the institution receives, as we did for Crowder College, where the study found about $2.30 in regional economic activity per taxpayer dollar. That ratio compares activity with funding. It is not a fiscal break-even test of whether tax receipts repay the appropriation, and the report says so.
